John Meyer Books
Ghostwriting a Memoir: 4 Rules Worth Considering
In “The Ghost,” the 2007 political thriller written by Robert Harris, each chapter begins with a ghostwriting rule Harris learned from real-life ghostwriter Andrew Crofts.
The rules aren’t part of the plot, and when I first read the book, I treated them as bonus material. Now that I’m a ghostwriter myself, with a book that made the national bestseller lists, I went back to see how the rules hold up in practice.
Of the 18 principles, these four currently resonate with me the most.
••••
Rule 1: The Publisher Wants a Hook
“The ghost will also be under pressure from the publishers to dig up something controversial that they can use to sell serial rights and to generate publicity at the time of publication.”
Mostly true. Not every subject has courted controversy, and thank the stars for that. However, a memoir must go far beyond a list of accomplishments that can be found on any LinkedIn page. That’s true for celebrity memoirs, too. Fame might inspire a lot of initial sales, but what will grab the readers who have never heard of the celeb?
The good news is that every life has a hook. It just isn’t always obvious to the person living it. “The Rise and Fall (and Possible Redemption) of X” is a decent starting point, but the book still needs spectacular scenes on both sides of that arc, and something to say that’s both universal and long-lasting. Finding that is where most of the work lies.
Rule 2: The Process Feels Like Therapy
“I have often been told by subjects that by the end of the research process, they feel as if they have been in therapy.”
Definitely true. It’s difficult to properly dissect and add meaning to every significant moment of our lives. We’re so invested in our own story that it’s hard to step back and ask what we’ve learned, what signs we missed, or which events foreshadowed others. It’s like watching a married couple argue. “Wow, they are so not right for each other.” That’s easy to say as an observer, and much harder when your heart and mind are completely devoted to (or trapped by) someone you love.
Many times in my conversations, the subject will stop and say, “I’ve never thought about that before.” Introspection usually follows. Sometimes an admission or even a confession follows, too. And if the tears suddenly arrive, I give them lots of room. There’s often something important about to be uncovered.
Rule 3: Listening Is Great, but Research Still Helps
“It is perfectly possible to write a book for someone, having done nothing but listen to their words; but extra research often helps to provide more material and descriptive ideas.”
Absolutely true. Context is king in any memoir. What’s true today wasn’t true ten, twenty, or thirty years ago. Today, you can track down anyone on your cell phone. In 2005, you either found a pay phone or went home and placed a proper phone call. Readers need to be reminded of where we were, what we did, and what we didn’t have. That comes from research.
Research also reminds us that we’re not in control of our universe. Outside forces collide, corrupt, and coddle us all the time. Think of the boss you resented because he wouldn’t listen to your requests. He may have been under tremendous pressure from his own boss, or facing financial trouble you never knew about. Back then, you had no way of seeing that. Today, you can.
We are all heroes in our own stories, but we’re also the victims, especially when we don’t know the whole story. An outsider’s deep dive into the past can fill in the gaps and shed new light on the decisions we made.
Rule 4: The Ghost Shouldn’t Challenge the Subject
“[Subjects] need ghosts who will not challenge them, but will simply listen to what they have to say and understand why they did what they did.”
This one’s tricky. Understanding why someone did what they did is essential, especially when the choices were difficult, regrettable, or controversial. That’s often where the most honest material lies.
But never challenging the subject makes a ghostwriter a blank slate, and a memoir written by a blank slate doesn’t always read well. A gentle challenge is sometimes needed to dig deeper into a motivation or to reflect more fully on the consequences. The subject may be the hero of the memoir, but their actions affected other people, and those people don’t get a say in this story. A little pushback, offered respectfully, can encourage healing, acknowledge accountability, or simply provide the context that makes the story more honest and more credible to readers.
The subject always has the final say on what goes into the book. The point of asking the hard questions in private is so that the book holds up in public.
••••
There are 14 other principles in Crofts’s list, and I suspect I’ll revisit a few more of them down the line. But these four rules have certainly given me a better appreciation of what a ghostwriter brings to the table. It’s not just about writing down someone else’s story verbatim. It’s about helping them narrow down the scope, discover what needs to be told, understand why it matters, and find a way to tell it so that others will want to read it. And yes, a little research and a little pushback go a long way too. It’s a relationship that can be therapeutic, and dare I say it, profitable too.
For more information about ghostwriting, check out:
